The makeup
of the “wall” is irrelevant. Whether it’s
made of concrete or steel slats doesn’t matter.
So, I’ll just call it a wall like Mr. Trump prefers.
Let’s look
at the geographical issues surrounding the wall:
California, Arizona, and New Mexico
Most of the
border, including and west of El Paso Texas, already has a wall / fence /
barriers. (existing border wall). The border around McAllen and Brownville
Texas, on the Gulf of Mexico, also already has a wall / fence / barriers.
Areas that do
not have a wall / fence / barrier in California, Arizona, and New Mexico are
generally impassable due to the terrain.
In other places the construction of a wall is cost prohibitive so the
border is guarded electronically or by human assets.
Texas
The Texas
border between the United States and Mexico is the Rio Grande River; a wide, fast
flowing river that originates in the Rocky Mountains in Colorado and is fed by
other rivers along the way.
What's the point of a wall when there's already a river?
Where can the Wall be Constructed?
We cannot
ignore the role of construction necessities and international politics in the construction
of the wall.
We seem to
assume that the wall will be built directly on the border line. This is nonsense. The Texas border is the centerline of the Rio
Grande river. We certainly cannot build
a wall in the middle of a river.
The sovereign
nation of The Republic of Mexico will not allow the United States to construct
a wall in Mexico; not even one inch. We can't go to war with Mexico for the wall. Therefore, the wall must be
entirely built within United States territory.
Nor will
Mexico allow American contractors to enter their country for the purpose of
building the wall. So, the wall must be
built within the United States and at some distance from the border; I would
guess, where the site is ideal, at least twenty to fifty feet.
Along the
Rio Grande, the restrictions get even more severe. If the wall is constructed to last it must be
outside of river’s flood plain, perhaps miles.
If not designed to last, the wall will be shown to be just a political
stunt.
The Wall Will Cede American Territory
Every President swears to protect American territory. The wall will, however, cede millions of acres of American land to Mexico.
Wherever we build a wall, the real border becomes the wall rather than the political border. The Berlin Wall moved the border between West and East Germany up to the edge of the wall. All of the land south of the wall becomes in reality Mexican territory.
In Texas, its
much worse. We would cede the Rio Grande
river along with miles of land extending into Texas to Mexico.
The reality
of the wall would be giving American territory to Mexico.
Border Guards Could Control the Land Between
the Wall and the Political Border
It’s true
that the land between the wall and the political border could be protected by
border guards (whether human or electronic).
But, isn’t this an admission that we don’t need the wall and it will
just be a waste of money?
The wall
cannot be constructed and will accomplish nothing. Call your Congress members and Senators.